Skip to content
ViolationScout18 new Class C against 8 certifications filed in the last 180 days.Is this your building?
Buildings417 Menahan Street, BrooklynCurrent through

417 Menahan St, Brooklyn

BBL 3-03312-0040

En español: 18 violaciones de Clase C abiertas (peligro inmediato) y 49 abiertas en total. La más antigua del HPD lleva 13 años abierta, desde el 17 de diciembre de 2012.

New violations are coming in faster than certifications are filed. 18 new Class C against 8 certifications filed in the last 180 days.

The oldest open HPD violation has been open 13 years, since December 17, 2012.

Since September 29, 2023, certifications were filed on 2 Class C violations, all 2 by the original certify-by date. How certification works

Is this your building?

18 open Class C. The oldest open HPD violation was filed December 17, 2012.

A firm we work with can take these on. We reply within one business day with the firm's name. You decide whether to talk to them. One firm, not a list.

Your details stay with us, and go only to the one firm you are introduced to. No lists, no resale.

¿Es su edificio? Déjenos un correo o un teléfono. Leemos cada solicitud.

See everything first: the building report, $19

Or file it yourself: what it can hold up, and how correction is filed

The case file on a building like this names who is responsible on HPD's registration and how to reach them. We prepare them for firms on our pilot, ranked by how much hazardous work is open.

Request a sample file

The building report reads this record for you: every open violation in the city's own words, what each status means, and how the building compares with others its size. Usually ready within 15 minutes of payment.

Get the report, $19

HPD takes complaints from tenants through 311.

DOB violations
18 active DOB violations, most of them for boiler filings under Local Law 62/91. The newest was issued February 24, 2017.
Housing court
1 open housing court case, opened May 12, 2026.
DOB complaints
2 DOB complaints in the 12 months to September 25, 2026. The newest was filed April 30, 2026.
Boiler inspection
Inspected August 13, 2026. Boilers in buildings with 6 or more apartments are inspected every calendar year.
HPD emergency repair orders
5 completed HPD emergency repair orders since September 29, 2023, awarded for $7,380 in total. The most recent of the 5, a general construction order, was opened September 19, 2025.

Open violations by class. A party is named only where the building's HPD registration covers the date a violation was filed.

FiledCategoryStatusNumberRegistered party when filed
Class C18 open most often Vermin / Infestation
Open19249243
Vermin / InfestationOpen19249242
Vermin / InfestationOpen19249233
Heat / Hot WaterNotice sent19170538ESTATE OF GABER MAHMOUD
Vermin / InfestationNotice sent to tenant19092018ESTATE OF GABER MAHMOUD
Vermin / InfestationNotice sent to tenant19092014ESTATE OF GABER MAHMOUD
Vermin / InfestationNotice sent to tenant19092013ESTATE OF GABER MAHMOUD
Fire SafetyNotice sent19092012ESTATE OF GABER MAHMOUD
Vermin / InfestationNotice sent to tenant19035747ESTATE OF GABER MAHMOUD
Vermin / InfestationNotice sent to tenant19035741ESTATE OF GABER MAHMOUD
The report lists all 18, each with the city's own words and the date on its notice. What the report adds
Class B27 open most often Fire Safety
Open19249241
Open19249239
Open19249237
Open19249235
Open19249234
Notice sent19092020ESTATE OF GABER MAHMOUD
Notice sent19092019ESTATE OF GABER MAHMOUD
Fire SafetyNo access to reinspect (first try)19092017ESTATE OF GABER MAHMOUD
Fire SafetyNo access to reinspect (first try)19092016ESTATE OF GABER MAHMOUD
No access to reinspect (first try)19092015ESTATE OF GABER MAHMOUD
The report lists all 27, each with the city's own words and the date on its notice. What the report adds
OATH/ECB4 open most often Construction
Construction, Class 2Found in violation39187643JESTATE OF GABER MAHMOUD
Construction, Class 2Found in violation39187642HESTATE OF GABER MAHMOUD
Construction, Class 1Found in violation39129896M
Construction, Class 1Found in violation39129297K

The full report on 417 Menahan St, Brooklyn

Get the report on 417 Menahan St, Brooklyn, $19 See a sample report

Usually ready within 15 minutes of payment, on your order page and by email. If it tells you nothing you did not already know, reply and we refund it.

The most common category among the open records here is vermin and pests.

Vermin and pests in Brooklyn

Nearby buildings

Questions about this building

Does 417 Menahan Street, Brooklyn have open violations?

Yes. 417 Menahan Street, Brooklyn had 49 open violations on September 27, 2026: 45 from HPD and 4 from OATH/ECB. 18 are Class C, the class HPD treats as immediately hazardous. The oldest open HPD violation has been open 13 years, since December 17, 2012.

Is 417 Menahan Street, Brooklyn getting better or worse?

New violations are coming in faster than certifications are filed. 18 new Class C against 8 certifications filed in the last 180 days. That window ends September 27, 2026. It compares certifications filed with new Class C violations, and it describes what happened, not what anyone intends.

When were certifications filed on Class C violations at 417 Menahan Street, Brooklyn?

Since September 29, 2023, certifications were filed on 2 Class C violations, all 2 by the original certify-by date. A certification is the filing, dated when it was made, not HPD's acceptance of it. It is compared with the original certify-by date on the notice. A granted postponement moves that date and the city's data keeps only the first, so a certification counted after it may still have met a postponed date.

Does 417 Menahan Street, Brooklyn have active DOB violations?

Yes. 18 active DOB violations, most of them for boiler filings under Local Law 62/91. The newest was issued February 24, 2017. The Department of Buildings writes these separately from HPD's housing violations, for things like boilers, elevators, facades, construction and energy filings. Each one stays active until DOB resolves or dismisses it.

Is 417 Menahan Street, Brooklyn in housing court?

Yes. 1 open housing court case, opened May 12, 2026. HPD takes buildings to housing court to get violations fixed and heat and hot water restored, and it joins tenants' own repair cases, called tenant actions. A case stays open until the court closes it.

Has DOB received complaints about 417 Menahan Street, Brooklyn?

Yes. 2 DOB complaints in the 12 months to September 25, 2026. The newest was filed April 30, 2026. Anyone can complain to DOB about a building or the work going on in it, and DOB then inspects and decides whether there is a violation. A conversion complaint says an apartment may have been added or changed without approval. It is a complaint, not a finding.

Are any HPD emergency repair orders at 417 Menahan Street, Brooklyn marked completed?

Yes. 5 completed HPD emergency repair orders since September 29, 2023, awarded for $7,380 in total. The most recent of the 5, a general construction order, was opened September 19, 2025. HPD orders an emergency repair when a hazardous condition cited in a violation, or in another agency's emergency order, is not corrected, and does the work itself or through a contractor. The amounts are what the orders were awarded for, not a bill: this page does not show what was charged to the property or whether it was paid. Orders for lab tests, such as dust-wipe and asbestos samples, are not counted.

When was the boiler at 417 Menahan Street, Brooklyn last inspected?

On August 13, 2026. DOB requires a boiler in a building with 6 or more apartments to be inspected once every calendar year, with the report filed within 14 days of the inspection. Low-pressure boilers in residential buildings with 5 or fewer apartments are exempt.

When was 417 Menahan Street, Brooklyn built?

The city's record gives 1931 as the year 417 Menahan Street, Brooklyn was built, in the Department of City Planning's PLUTO tax-lot file. The same file classes it as a walk-up apartment building with 3 floors.

How many apartments does 417 Menahan Street, Brooklyn have?

The Department of City Planning's PLUTO tax-lot file lists 6 residential units at 417 Menahan Street, Brooklyn. The count is for the whole tax lot.

Where do these numbers come from?

From New York City's own data: HPD housing violations and OATH/ECB hearing results, read whole rather than sampled. It also draws on DOB violations, HPD's housing court cases, DOB complaints, HPD emergency repair orders, DOB boiler inspection reports and the city's PLUTO tax-lot file. This page is current through September 27, 2026. The city's data changes daily, so a violation certified after that can still show as open here; the city's own page for this building is linked above.

Sources. HPD housing violations and OATH/ECB hearing results, plus DOB violations, HPD's housing court cases, DOB complaints, HPD emergency repair orders, DOB boiler inspection reports and the city's PLUTO tax-lot file. Counts cover HPD Class B and C violations from the last 3 years that HPD still shows open, and OATH/ECB summonses from the same 3 years that the city still shows active. The city's own pages can show more, never fewer.

Cite this page

ViolationScout, 417 Menahan St, Brooklyn: 18 open Class C, from New York City's HPD violation and OATH/ECB hearing data. Figures through September 27, 2026. https://violationscout.com/building/417-menahan-street-brooklyn

How we count: /method.

Is this your building?